Arguments and Studies Supporting/Against Business and IT/IS Strategy Alignment
The argument will be drawn from various literatures example (Brancheau, Janz, & Wetherbe, 1996) discovered that in 68 organizations IS/IT manager failed to align IS with business. (Lederer & Mendel, 1989) also found that coordination of IS/IT with business is the second challenge to 107 organizations and should be tackled greatly.
Dearden as cited in the work of (Janson, 1989) claims from the case he represented in his work of different business organizations ranging from small to large, that IS/IT with business alignment should not be taken in isolation. He stresses on the need for IS/IT irrespective of organization size.
McBride as cited in the work of (Abdisalam Issa-Salwe, 2010) emphasises through his description on the pattern in which organizations accomplish the value of its peak using some identified IT/IS basic.Henderson and Venkatraman, describe in one of their paper that strategic alignment involves IT infrastructure, business strategy, IT strategy and business infrastructure between functional Integration and strategic fit. (Henderson & Venkatraman, 1993).(Luftman 2000) equally support the motion that strategic alignment refers to applying information technology together with business strategy aims in other to make IT become a driver.
In contrast (Ciborra, 1997) also argued that even if there may be some green light in strategic alignment, the outcome diminishes shortly. Smaczny opines from his anecdotal evidence, experience as a CIO with various years of in banking companies, that IT/IS should be seen as a function which is fused into the business. That is IT/IS should be discovered and implanted at the same time not considering alignment. (Smaczny, 2001)
According to (Beveridge, nd) an independent consultant of the National Computing Centre Information technology strategies are often bolted on to the business as an afterthought rather than being viewed as a business driver. This situation can only be rectified by obtaining an indebt alignment of the various IT infrastructures like the efficiency drive and the need to differentiate dive for effectiveness. For instance Nugent (2004, p 1 cited in the work of (Grant, Hackney, & Edgar, 2010) opines that ‘IT/business alignment is not a “nice-to-have”; it is a “must-have” because it brings lasting reward’. For this reason information system strategy should not be set as a subsequent task where the business goals may have probably been set with slightly different focus. Information system strategy should mainly be established as an integral part of the business strategy.
References:
Abdisalam Issa-Salwe, M. A. (2010, March). Strategic Information Systems Alignment:Alignment of IS/IT with Business Strategy. Journal of Information Processing Systems, vol.6, P 121-124. doi:10.3745/JIPS.2010.6.1.121
Brancheau, J. C., Janz, B. D., & Wetherbe, J. C. (1996, June). Key issues in information system management. MIS QUARTERLY, 20, 242-225. Retrieved June 15, 2013
Grant, K., Hackney, R., & Edgar, D. (2010). Strategic Informtion System Management. United Kingdom: Seng Lee Press. Retrieved May 29, 2013
Lederer, A., & Salmela, H. (1996). Toward a theory of strategic information system planing. Journal of Strategic Information Systems, vol 5, 237-253. Retrieved June 18, 2013
Smaczny, T. (2001, October). IT an alignment between business and IT the appropriate paradigm to manage IT in todays organization. Management Decision(ISSN 0025-1747), 797-802. Retrieved June 18, 2013, from http//:www.emerald-library.com/ft